Let's discover history together
Discovering the history
Saturday, 21 February 2026
Educated But Invisible: The Victorian Governess and Her Place in the Household
The Rise of the Detective: Finding Order in a Changing Victorian World
The Rise of the Detective: Finding Order in a Changing Victorian World
I have been discovering more about different aspects of Victorian life, and today I thought we could find out about the rise of the police and more to the point, the detective. This was a new profession but it also became a new kind of fictional hero. This response was possibly a reaction to a world that suddenly felt like it had become bigger, faster, and even more uncertain than ever before, a time where people were desperate for some type of reassurance that someone, anyone could make sense of all the chaos. This sounds familiar, doesn’t it?
Lets start the beginning of the nineteenth century, when the idea of organised policing as still a relatively new idea and was by many viewed with a certain amount of suspicion. Many people were worried that a professional police force might threaten their personal freedoms in some way. They had visions of systems that had been in place abroad, particularly in France. These systems were seen as way too heavy-handed even to the point of oppressive. Crime existed, of course it did, but communities were used to dealing with it on a local level. They used watchmen or parish constables. These were local men, not professionals and they were responsible for keeping watch and maintaining order. There was a sense that justice was more immediate, even if it was not always effective. For ordinary people, feeling safe depended more on knowing their neighbours than on any official authority.
In 1829, things had started to change. The Metropolitan Police were established in London under Home Secretary Robert Peel. They were a uniformed, organised force. This was a huge turning point. The new officers, who soon became nicknamed “Bobbies,” walked the streets in blue coats, intended to be approachable rather than in any way military, but also a visible deterrent. For some Londoners, their presence brought them a feeling of safety. Streets that used to be dangerous now had regular patrols.
Despite this growing fascination, not everyone was entirely comfortable with this new kind of policing. Some Victorians worried about the idea of men watching people and gathering information. There were fears about privacy and the possible mistakes, and some critics even wondered whether too much power rested in the hands of just a few individuals. Similar concerned are often raised today with the use of facial recognition. But at the same time, many people did actually feel reassured knowing that there were skilled people working to solve crime. The suspicion and the trust reflected the wider Victorian society, a world learning to balance tradition with rapid change.
The role of the police, as you know, did eventually become more accepted, particularly as cities grew in the Industrial Revolution. Urban life did bring opportunities but it also caused serious overcrowding, poverty, and a rising anxiety about crime. Newspapers reported on thefts, assaults, and sensational trials, which fed into the public appetite for stories that were both frightening and compelling. Readers could not look away. Crime stories allowed them to confront their fears from a safe distance while also reassuring themselves that there will always be someone to put things right.
Out of this mix of anxiety, fascination, and social change came the first detectives. In 1842, the Metropolitan Police created its first Detective Branch, that later became known as the Criminal Investigation Department. Unlike the uniformed officers, detectives worked in plain clothes, they relied on observations, deductions and patience rather than the visible authority and deterrent that the “Bobbies” used.
To the Victorian imagination, this must have seemed almost mysterious. The detective was not just a figure who upheld the law but someone who was intelligent, someone who could see things that other people missed.
Real detectives quickly captured the public’s attention. Figures like Inspector Charles Frederick Field became minor celebrities of the time. Stories about their investigations appeared in newspapers and magazines, mixing fact with just a touch of drama. People were fascinated not only by the crimes themselves but by the process used to solve them. There was a growing belief that reason and persistence could restore some balance, a comforting thought for people in an age of rapid change.
One reason that detectives captured the public imagination so strongly was the growing number of famous criminal cases that filled the newspapers. Trials and investigations became kind of public entertainment. They were followed closely by readers wanting every new detail. Cases like the shocking Road Hill House case of 1860 showed Victorian England that brutality that could exist behind respectable peoples doors. The painstaking work detectives took to uncover the truth was also becoming interesting to the public. Later in the century, Jack the Ripper terrified London and showed the importance of detective work, as the fear spread through the crowded streets of the East End. For Victorians reading these stories, must have been complex- they must have felt horror at the crimes, but also a fascination with the process of investigation and a deep hope that justice could be delt.
Image info:
Sherlock Holmes in "The Man with the Twisted Lip"
Date: December 1891
Source: The Strand Magazine
Author: Sidney Paget
Literature was also starting to reflect this new fascination. Earlier crime stories had often focused on the criminals or on the moral lessons that can be learned, but by the mid-nineteenth century, authors had begun to place the investigator front and centre of the story. One of the earliest was Edgar Allan Poe’s detective C. Auguste Dupin. Although Poe was American, his influence shaped British writers who saw the potential for a new kind of story that was built around puzzles and intelligence.
Charles Dickens whose interest was in the workings of society, also played a role in popularising the detective genre. His friendship with Inspector Field helped to create his characters, this offered readers a glimpse into the investigative work. Dickens understood that crime stories were not just exciting but could also be emotional. They reflected the fears people had about poverty, inequality, and the hidden struggles of urban life. Through his writing, people could feel both sympathy and suspense, and he recognised that crime often came from hardship as much as it did from any malice.
By the late nineteenth century, the detective had fully captured the Victorian imagination. No figure is more famous Sherlock Holmes, an incredible creation of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. Holmes first appeared in 1887, and he was and still is the perfect mix of logic and unique personality. He used his observational skills, scientific methods, and a confidence to solve the most baffling mysteries. For the audience who were living in an era of scientific discovery and social change, this must have felt reassuring as well and entertaining.
Image info:Charlton Comics
Date: October 1955
But Holmes was not admired just for his intellect. He also felt human in his own way, he struggled with moments of isolation and intensity that gave a taste at the emotional cost of seeing things clearly. Dr Watson his loyal and steadying companion provided perspective, and this reminded audiences that friendship and empathy also mattered. Together, they created a partnership that felt both balanced and comforting, alongside the excitement and emotional connection. It is no wonder they are still so incredibly popular today, with so many different adaptations made in to films and series. They satisfy our curiosity and our need for answers. Even as the methods of investigation change, the appeal of solving mysteries and restoring order still continues to resonate with audiences today.
Do you think the popularity of detectives reflects the human need to believe that truth can always be uncovered, even in uncertain times?
Thursday, 19 February 2026
Eliza Roberts: The Nurse History Almost Forgot
The Matchgirls’ Strike: Courage in the Face of Injustice
The English Reformation: Faith, Fear, and the Fight for Authority
Wednesday, 18 February 2026
In Service and Silence: The Long Life of Louisa McDonnell, Countess of Antrim
Anna Maria Russell and the Social Ritual That Changed British Afternoons
Educated But Invisible: The Victorian Governess and Her Place in the Household
Educated Bet Invisible: The Victorian Governess and Her Place in the Household I have been learning more about the lives of the Victorians, ...
-
BOSWORTH FIELD Bosworth Field was a hugely important part of British history, it was the start of the Tudor dynasty. Everybody has heard of...
-
Arthur, Prince of Wales circa 1500 Private collection, Hever Castle, Kent Arthur, Prince of Wales was born on the 19th or 20th o...
-
Richard III: Overview. Richard III: A Controversial King Public Domain. https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:King_Richard_I...